Environmental Law requires collaboration between scientists and lawyers
25 February 2020
Hi, Yaffa Epstein, researcher at Department of Law. You are researching how scientific terms are used in environmental law, together with ecologists from SLU. What will you do in the project?
of Law. Photo: Tobias Björkgren
– Initially we're trying to look at how to combine legal and ecological expertise to interpret some terms, all of which have natural-scientific aspects, that are used in several EU directives related to environmental protection. Then we hope to construct a general theory on how legal and natural scientists can work together to interpret these types of terms in the law or even more broadly how to communicate across scientific disciplines.
Why is this a particular problem in environmental law?
– Because environmental law is about managing the human relationship with nature, so pretty much every environmental law is going to involve the non-human, which has to be understood through scientific intermediaries. One example is that species populations should be viable according to the EU Habitats Directive, but viable isn't further defined in that law. So you have to talk to an ecologist about what makes a species population viable, which isn´t a clear cut question for a scientist either, as it involves the question of how high an extinction risk we want to accept. Nobody really has monopoly on defining viability.
How, then, can lawyers better communicate with natural scientists and experts?
– Talking past each other is a common difficulty in interdisciplinary collaboration. What I´m working on is a method to argue with each other constructively rather than to ignore communication problems. Lawyers get to define terms, even scientific terms, as they’re used in the law, but at the same time legal requirements need to make senseto those in other scientific disciplines so the law can be effectively applied. There is always going to be some interaction, necessarily.
Do the laws need to be rewritten to be clear and specific enough?
– No, a law can't cover every situation or define everything. But it's important to be conscientious about when interpreting the law requires scientific input or value judgements.
Researcher in environmental law
Yaffa Epstein is a researcher in environmental law at Uppsala University’s Department of Law. Her special focus has been on protection of Sweden and other countries’ wolf populations in relation to regulation under EU law and its influence on wildlife conservation. She obtained her PhD in 2017 and since then her research has attracted keen interest in both scientific contexts and among the informed public. In 2019 she received Uppsala University’s Oscar Prize for young researchers.
More News in English
- Gustaf Almkvist new Doctor of Law in Criminal Law at Uppsala University
- Jonatan Schytzer new Doctor of Law in Private Law at Uppsala University
-
The Faculty of Law at Uppsala University announces six doctoral positions
The Faculty of Law at Uppsala University announces six doctoral positions among which five are general doctoral positions and one in jurisprudence.
- New publication on legal action in connection with the Covid-19 pandemic
-
The Winter Courses 2021 - The Hague Academy of International Law, 11-29 January 2021
Inger Österdahl is taking part in The Winter Courses 2021 at The Hague Academy of International Law with lectures on ”The Regulation of the Interne...
-
Emeritus professor Jan Darpö about a study of “Rights of Nature in a European Context”
Emeritus professor Jan Darpö has been assigned by the European Parliament to undertake a study of “Rights of Nature in a European Context”
- Raised security in Zoom-classes
-
Erika P Björkdahl: new expert
Erika P Björkdahl has been appointed expert in an inquiry on the situation and quality of renting.
- Katia Cejie: new Deputy Member of the EATLP Academic Committee 2020-2023
-
Victoria Enkvist, Seth Epstein and Marianne Dahlén have received a grant from Formas
Victoria Enkvist, Seth Epstein and Marianne Dahlén have received a grant from Formas for the research project Realizing the rights of nature. Does ...
- We welcome our new doctoral students: Who are they? What are their research projects about?
- New Professor in Public International Law
- New book of Therése Fridström Montoya
- New book of Moa Kindström Dahlin and colleagues about Religion, Migration, and Existential Wellbeing
- Mikael Ruotsi has been appointed expert
-
New Dean and Vice-Deans from July 1st
On July 1st 2020, Professor Anna Singer will take over as Dean of the Faculty of Law together with Professor Anna Jonsson Cornell and Associate Pro...
- Professor at the Faculty of Law appointed expert by the government
-
Olle Lundin: Knowing where the law draws the line
How are local politicians and officials at public agencies actually allowed to behave? And what does the law say about procurement, conflict of int...
-
Having difficulties returning your library books?
The spreading of the corona virus makes it difficult for some users to return their books.
- Matariki Lecture 2020: Virus-X – exploring the structural and functional diversity of the Virosphere
-
Environmental Law requires collaboration between scientists and lawyers
Hi, Yaffa Epstein, researcher at Department of Law. You are researching how scientific terms are used in environmental law, together with ecologist...
- A Journey into the Italian Justice System - Seminar on Constitutional Law
-
Uppsala researcher an expert in the investigation of a prohibition of racist organisations
Anna-Sara Lind has been appointed to serve as an expert on the committee investigating the issue of potentially prohibiting racist organisations. W...
- Information from the Swedish National Union of Students
-
Beyond the current day hype of AI
Anna-Sara Lind, Uppsala University, is the project leader for the project Artificial Intelligence, Democracy and Human Dignity. Together with her r...
-
PhD position - among others in the field of Law and Artificial Intelligence - current to apply
A number of positions in postgraduate education in law are open for application. Among other positions, a targeted position where the concentration...
-
Uppsala researcher an expert in the investigation of a prohibition of racist organisations
Anna-Sara Lind has been appointed to serve as an expert on the committee investigating the issue of potentially prohibiting racist organisations. W...
- Katia Cejie on the Distinguished Teaching Award for 2019
-
The EU and Swedish corporate taxation
On behalf of the Centre for Business and Policy Studies (SNS), Professor Mattias Dahlberg has authored a book on the EU and corporate taxation (Sto...
-
New book on European family law
Research in international demand in the field of family law has recently been collated in the book ‘Principles of European Family Law Regarding Pro...
-
Researcher in the Faculty of Law is granted a large sum by the Swedish Research Council
Researcher in the Faculty of Law at Uppsala University, Moa Lidén, is granted a large sum by the Swedish Research Council for her research over the...
-
Oscar Prize 2019 for environmental law and palaeontology researchers
The winners of Uppsala University’s Oscar Prize for young researchers are Yaffa Epstein of the Department of Law and Grzegorz Niedzwiedzki of the D...
-
New Honorary Doctor at the Faculty of Law
Professor Hans Petter Graver of the University of Oslo was recently named the new Honorary Doctor by the Faculty of Law.
-
Anna-Sara Lind member of WASP-HS management team
Anna-Sara Lind, Professor of Public Law at the Faculty of Law, has been appointed to the management team of “WASP-HS”, the Wallenberg AI, Autonomou...
-
Train to Enforce – a new EU project
Train to Enforce is a combined research and training project aimed at facilitating free movement within the EU for judgments, primarily related to ...
-
Major investment in research on impact of artificial intelligence on people and society
A major national research programme aims to study the impact of artificial intelligence on society at large and on individual behaviour. The Marian...
-
Festschrift presented to Kaj Hobér
Upon his retirement, Professor of International Investment and Trade Law Kaj Hobér was presented with the Festschrift Forward! Bперёд! Framåt! : Es...
-
Anna-Sara Lind appointed expert in government inquiry on constitutional torts
A committee was appointed last year to study the right to governmental damages upon breaches of rights and freedoms protected by the Swedish Consti...
-
Premier for the Bachelor's Programme in Land Management, specialising in law
The term has now begun at Uppsala University, bringing with it the start of an entirely new degree programme: The Bachelor's Programme in Land Mana...
-
New term at the Faculty of Law
New and returning students are being welcomed this week to our law programme, master’s programmes and the various courses we offer. For the second ...
-
Progressive jurisprudence in the late-capitalist era?
In response to his latest book, Poverty Law and Legal Activism: Lives That Slide out of View, Professor Adam Gearey of Birkbeck College, University...
-
Mattias Dahlberg reappointed to the Swedish Council for Advance Tax Rulings
The Swedish government has decided to reappoint Mattias Dahlberg, professor of fiscal law, as a member of the Council for Advance Tax Rulings for a...
-
Anna-Sara Lind appointed expert in government inquiry
Professor of Public Law Anna-Sara Lind at the Faculty of Law was recently appointed to serve as an expert adviser to the government inquiry on Publ...
-
Erika P. Björkdahl honoured as Teacher of the Year
The Uppsala Law Student Association has voted Erika P. Björkdahl, senior lecturer in private law, as Teacher of the Year for the 2019 law programme.
-
New volume of De lege with articles and speeches by honorary doctors at the Faculty of Law, Uppsala
The book “Law and Society. Contributions by the Honorary Doctors” was recently published as part of the Faculty of Law’s De lege series.
-
Juridicum wishes you a nice summer!
The Department of Law is closed during the summer and welcomes you back as from 19 August.
-
Vinnova funds Human Rights Clinic
The Faculty of Law has been running a Human Rights Clinic since 2016, funded by Vinnova. The clinic was recently awarded additional funding of SEK ...
-
Bengt Domeij new head of department at the Faculty of Law
Professor of Private Law Bengt Domeij will accede as the head of the Department of Law on 1 July 2019. He succeeds Professor of Private Law Margare...
-
Maarit Jänterä-Jareborg elected a member of Academia Europaea
Maarit Jänterä-Jareborg, Professor of Private International Law and International Civil Procedure, was recently elected a member of Academia Europa...
-
Anna-Sara Lind retained as member of the Swedish Migration Agency Ethics Council
The appointment of Professor of Public Law Anna-Sara Lind, Faculty of Law, to the Migration Agency Ethics Council has been extended.